“WHY the
heavy police presence?” a woman asked, nervously
surveying the gangs of plod stalking the Albert
Hall arena. “There’s been a disappearance,” said
the young constable. “It’s a reconstruction.”
Life’s never dull with Graham Vick, and the
director took advantage of the Proms’ first-ever
staged opera to bring a highly Vickian walkabout
production of Britten’s “church parable” to
London. And a most arresting event it was too,
saving your honour.
These police were part
of the show, of course: a Vick speciality, to
startle the audience and bring it into the play.
And Curlew River does indeed deal with a
disappearance: the Madwoman is roaming in search
of her son who vanished a year ago, and finally
learns of his fate as she takes a boat across
the river with a group of pilgrims on their way
to visit a miracle-working shrine.
William Plomer made the libretto from a
medieval Japanese Noh play, and moved the thing
to the English fenlands, having it
ritualistically performed by a group of monks as
a celebration of God’s grace: the shrine turns
out to be the boy’s, and his spirit comforts the
mother.
Performing this as a police reconstruction
might sound laughable but was far from it: it’s
as close to ritual as we get in these days of
Crimewatch and 999, and the cops
arguably fulfil the same double-edged authority
role the Church did in the Middle Ages. What
Vick does is to abolish the distance of staged
events: Mark Wilde’s Madwoman becomes every
distraught bereaved mother with his banal little
empty pushchair. And God ’s grace, in a hopeful
post-religious vision, becomes a moment of human
connection and sympathy as a section of the
audience were brought to terms with their own
griefs.
“Closure” has been too spuriously aired
lately to have much currency, but this stark,
dignified staging made something immediate from
Britten’s contemplative drama. The Birmingham
Contemporary Music Group played the blurry music
with delicacy, and the whole thing was a glimpse
of how, with imagination, the Albert Hall can
become a vividly contemporary space of shared
experience, not just a Victorian barn.
Earlier, Kurt Masur and the LPO played the
most tactile Schubert Unfinished Symphony, full
of glimpses deep into the German Romantic
forest, with Janácek’s bombastic Glagolitic
Mass and his Hukvaldy Songs, as
regrettable as the next
folk-song.